December 19th, 2024
A simple proof of the Cayley-Bacharach theorem
A lot of proofs of the Cayley-Bacharach theorem posted online often require some extensive algebraic geometry background. This blog post hopefully highlights certain properties of linear combinations in hopes of providing a rock-solid proof
The Cayley-Bacharach theorem states:
If two cubics and intersect at 9 points, and a third cubic passes through 8 of the 9th point, then it will also pass through the 9th intersection point, as well.
Proof
We have three cubics, , , and .
Because and are degree curves, by Bézout's theorem, and will intersect on at most points. Another way to say this is that and will share common vanishing points. Also worded alternatively, the zero set of both and will be those 9 points. Also note that the linear combination of and forms a pencil that will span the space of all cubics that pass through those 9 points.
Let's have it so that the third cubic passes through 8 of the 9 points of the intersections of and .
This means that the space of cubics that pass through those 8 points—for which , , and will be a part of—imposes 8 linear condition. Because of this, the space of cubics that pass through these 8 points is expressible as a system of 8 cubic equations. Solving for it will thus leave us with a linear combination of two cubics, giving us again a pencil of cubics that pass through those 8 points. And again, the span of which includes , , and .
This means that can be expressible as a linear combination of and .
By Bézout's theorem, not only the span will share those 8 vanishing points, but will also all 9 vanishing points.
This proof has been inspired by one written by Matthias Volk, over at his blog post "Cayley-Bacharach theorem".